Is it illegal to ask for a review?
By Asaf Shamly, founder · Last updated November 16, 2026 · 6 min read
Asking a customer for an honest review isn't illegal. The FTC's Consumer Review Rule, in effect since October 21, 2024, bans faking reviews, paying for a specific sentiment, hiding insider connections, and burying bad feedback. Violations can run up to $53,088 each, and there's no small-business exemption.
Is it illegal to ask for a review?
No. Asking a customer for an honest review is allowed, and the FTC says so directly. The rule that took effect October 21, 2024 targets how reviews get faked, bought, or hidden. It doesn't touch the act of asking.
Where contractors get into trouble is the method, not the request. Skip the homeowner you know was unhappy about the tear-off, promise a discount for five stars, or let your spouse post a review without saying who she is and you've crossed a line that has nothing to do with simply asking.
The FTC's 2024 review rule carries real financial teeth
What does the FTC rule actually ban?
The rule, found at 16 CFR Part 465, covers six practices. Five show up in home service businesses often: fake or AI-written reviews, incentives tied to sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, company sites posing as independent, and pressure tactics used to scrub bad feedback.
Sections 465.2, 465.4, 465.5, 465.6, and 465.7 are the ones that matter if you're collecting reviews from real customers. None of them say you can't ask. They say you can't rig the result.
Is review bombing legal?
Review bombing, where people flood a listing with fake or coordinated negative reviews they never earned, is itself a form of fake review activity the rule prohibits. A review has to reflect a real experience with the product or service.
A business hit by a bombing campaign can report it to the app. What it can't do is use groundless legal threats or false accusations to force any review down, good or bad. That's suppression and it's its own violation.
Can you trust incentivized reviews?
Not if the incentive depends on what the review says. The rule bans offering a gift card, a discount, or a free truck roll in exchange for a positive review. The condition doesn't need to be written down. If the ask implies leave five stars and get the perk, that counts.
An incentive that applies no matter what the customer says, and is disclosed, is a different story. The problem is sentiment tied to reward, not reward on its own.
Is it illegal to pay someone for a review?
Yes, if the payment buys a specific outcome. Purchased reviews are banned outright, and so is paying anyone, including a competitor's customer, to post a negative review about someone else.
Civil penalties can reach $53,088 per violation, and the FTC counts each fake or bought review separately. Stack up a handful of them and the number climbs fast for a crew that never thought of itself as a target.
How do I write a Google review for my business?
You don't. Writing a review of your own company, or having an officer, manager, employee, or close relative do it without disclosing who they are, is one of the clearest violations in the rule. Managers are also limited in asking employees or immediate relatives for reviews at all.
The safe version is simple: ask the actual customer, ask every customer the same way, and never touch the text yourself.
What this means for a contractor
For a contractor running a small crew, the fix is mostly about consistency, not legal review. Ask every customer who finished a job, not just the ones you're sure were happy, and never dangle a discount for a specific star count on the driveway handshake or the second quote.
Disclose it plainly if an employee or a relative ever leaves a review of the business. WorkBrag's review ask goes out to every finished job the same way, by text, with no sentiment filter built in, no callback needed to trigger it.
Keep a simple log of who got asked and when. If a letter ever shows up, you can show the pattern was the same for everyone, from the first truck roll to the last.
Methodology
Rule effective date, the six banned practices, and the specific sections (465.2, 465.4, 465.5, 465.6, 465.7) come from Resident Review's contractor guide to the FTC rule. The description of incentive and insider-disclosure requirements comes from Crowell & Moring's client alert on the FTC's first enforcement sweep.
The per-violation penalty figure of $53,088 and the confirmation that the FTC applies the rule to businesses of every size come from Forward Law Firm's small business FAQ on the FTC.
Frequently asked questions
Does the review rule apply to small contracting businesses?
Yes. The FTC applies the rule the same way to a five-truck plumbing company as it does to a national retailer, and there is no small-business carve-out.
What is the penalty for violating the review rule?
Civil penalties can reach up to $53,088 per violation, and the FTC counts each fake or bought review separately, so a batch of them adds up fast.
Can I offer a reward for leaving a review?
Only if the reward doesn't depend on the review being positive and any connection is disclosed. Offering a discount specifically for a five-star review is prohibited under the rule.
Sources
Read next
The 48-hour rule: when to ask for a review
Asking for a review more than 48 hours after the job cuts response about 40%. The timing, the one reminder that matters, and what a same-day text gets.
Hub / ReviewsHow to ask for a review by text, not pushy
Ask within 2 hours, one reminder at day 3-5, never offer anything. Three short text scripts, the direct Google review link, and how to handle a bad one.
ReviewsWhat homeowners see in solar installer review searches
A look at how CNET, EcoWatch, and SolarReviews score solar installers, and what homeowners check before they ever read a customer review.